[ ESO ]

MACAO-CRIRES:

curvature adaptive optics for CRIRES

HOME INDEX SEARCH HELP NEWS


 

Built by: ESO
related instrument:
CRIRES
AO-System responsible: Jérôme Paufique
Instrument Scientist: Ulli Käufl
Team: P. Biereichel, B.Delabre, E. Fedrigo, D. Gojak, N. Hubin, S. Oberti, J.L. Lizon, E. Pozna,S. Tordo
Location: VLT Nasmyth UT1
Status: AO stand-alone commissioning in April 06, CRIRES 1st comm. June 2006
Foreseen Schedule: August: comm.2, science verification 3Q 06

Contents


High resolution spectroscopy and the VLT

High resolution spectroscopy requires either small slit size or long focal lengths. In CRIRES, to fit the requirements of a Nasmyth instrument in weight and dimensions and to accomodate for existing grating sizes, the choice was made of a 0.2" slit. This rather small aperture naturally led to consider the use of adaptive optics. The adaptive optics allow to shrink the size of a star image below this slit size, increasing at the same time the star-background contrast.
MACAO-CRIRES, the adaptive optics of the infrared Echelle spectrograph for the VLT, is a 60 actuators adaptives optics, allowing to compensate seeings up to 1.5 arcsec.
You will find hereafter all you always wanted to know about this system without even knowing it...

the MACAO-concept in the VLT
MACAO stands for Multi-application curvature adaptive optics.  The project covers three types of instruments, already in service in Paranal or soon to be operated:
  • on VLTI, the Very large telescope interferometer and its dedicated instrumentation; with its MACAO adaptive optics located at the Coudé focus of the 8-m telescopes and with the 1.8 m Auxiliary telescopes, the VLTI will provide both a high sensitivity as well as milli-arcsec angular resolution provided by baselines of up to 200m length,
  • on SINFONI, an Integral field unit spectrometer, providing 1500- to 4000 resolution spectra of a 32x32 pixels area; each pixel covering 25x25, 100x100 or 250x250 mas on the sky, and
  • on CRIRES, a high-resolution (R=100 000) infrared spectrometer, with a 0.2" wide slit on the sky. Its MACAO-based adaptive optics will improve both flux and spatial resolution on the targets. 
MACAO-CRIRES is based on a 60-actuators deformable mirror (DM); the optics can compensate at a 3-sigma level the atmospheric wavefront curvature averaged over any actuator area, up to a 1” seeing . The curvature signal produced by the membrane mirror is split by a lenslet array unit, and the
The Strehl ratio provided by this system can exceed 60% for a bright star and good sky conditions, and will be better than 40% in some 75% of the photometric night time (see the page related to the Paranal site measurements for more statistical informations about the turbulence characteristics of the atmosphere above the observatory).
perfos system  

Commissioning run

In April 2006, the AO module of CRIRES has been commissioned in stand-alone mode, and has shown performances in agreement with the expectations. Strehl ratios of up to 60% have been measured in good to medium seeing conditions, and even for rather poor seeing of up to 1.1", good performances have been shown (consistently above 50% of flux concentrated in a 0.2" square pixel). The good results of this commissioning have paved the road for the commissioning of the whole instrument (see the CRIRES webpage for more details). Data obtained with the Infrared test camera (Ks-band, sometimes as well in J, H) are available through ESO archive (packages Ids 4352-4362), and a short description of the data available is given here.


close binary (85 mas) HD105196
close binary, as seen on the infrared test camera used during the AO-commissioning. The separation between both components is only 85 mas, equivalent to the distance between both eyes of a passenger of the ISS, as seen from the ground!!




Best Strehl achieved during the commissioning of 61% (star R=12)
Best image obtained from the AO-commissioning; the Strehl ratio reaches 61% on this image.



ANt nebula FeII line


R=10 R=13.5
R=15
R=17.4
Ensquared energy,
good seeing
63%
58%
-
-
ensquared energy,
bad seeing
56%
50%
43%
30%
best Strehl achieved
61%
47%
25%
(6%)
Performance of the system: good seeing conditions were considered when the seeing was below 0.78”, while the bad seeing conditions were considered when the seeing was above 0.73” (DIMM measurements). The Strehl values and ensquared energy indicated are given for K-band, taking into account the aberrations introduced by the infrared test camera (82%), and are therefore pessimistic. The Strehl value is only indicative for R=17.4 star, as the meaning of the Strehl starts loosing its pertinence at such low values.





Optomechanical overview

The relay optics
MACAO-CRIRES is located at the Nasmyth focus, and inserted in a one-to-one optical relay allowing as well the calibration of the spectrograph (iodine cells, integrating sphere and calibration lamps, ...). The design of the relay is based on one spherical mirror, corrected for its astigmatism by two folding long-radius of curvature mirrors. 60 mm before the focus, the light is split into its infrared part, directed toward the spectrograph, and the reflected visible part, used by the wavefront sensor. The deformable mirror is inserted on the path.
The compensation of the aberrations is excellent in the center of the field, but degrades within the field. The optics keep nevertheless the optical energy within 0.2" (the slit width) over the whole field. It is to be noted that at this distance (25" on the sky), the anisoplanetic angle introduces by itself more than 300 nm rms.

A calibration unit (for spectrographic and adaptive optics purpose) is located at the Nasmyth focus, before a 3-mirrors derotator. It includes several calibration sources and absorption cells, as well as artificial stars, allowing turbulence-free calibrations of the AO system. The whole warm optics assembly is located on a breadboard, which can be covered by dark panels, to allow day-time calibrations. On the picture, a part of this cover is visible with the cable feedthrough, on the top-right (before black anodisation).
top view of the real warm part top view
Left: top view of the warm optics of CRIRES (including the wavefront sensor), with an overlay showing the beam path; right: top view of the the WFS components.

The wavefront sensor optics
A field scanning lens is located right after the visible f/15 focus, which collimates the light and reimages the pupil at the focal plane of the reimaging lens, a 70 mm diameter lens (only 50 mm will be used, but the lens was designed and  realised to fit both SINFONI and CRIRES optical designs). the reimaging lens has a focal of 290 mm, producing an f/47 beam at its output. The light inputs then a membrane mirror, which oscillation are producing the curvature signal sensed later on.
A spherical mirror collimates the light coming from the membrane mirror, while re-imaging the pupil at the entrance of a beam expander. The beam expander is based on a two off-axis parabola afocal lens. It enlarges the beam to a diameter of 14 mm, while forming a real image of the pupil at the level of a lenslet array. After the membrane mirror, aberration in the optics will essentially lead to a blurring of the pupil images, without affecting directly the measurement of curvature itself. Therefore, the optical quality of the beam expander has been relaxed up to 120 nm rms, affecting only marginally the performances.


WFS layout
side view of the WFS optics, including the fibre bundle head


the fibre bundle and APD rack
The lenslet array is the point at which the light is split in 60 distinct optical channels, to be processed later on. We chose a two-step assembly: a first lenslet reproducing the geometry of the DM and focusing the light of each subaperture on a second lenslet, acting as a Fabry lens which images the subaperture on a fibre entrance. This Fabry lens prevents the system suffering from injection losses related to the tip-tilt at the level of the subaperture.
For the first lenslets, Heptagon (Swiss) improved their technological performances to manufacture high depth lenslets (up to 25 micron), the laser writing of a master before replicas are produced out of it9. The second lenslet array has been realised by Microfab, an american company manufacturing  lenslets through a process of micro-deposition of droplets (inkjet-like), producing high quality of geometrical properties of the pattern (in our case, half-ball lenses, 0.7mm of diameter, about 0.5 mm of useful aperture). The light is then injected in 60 fibres, positioned with a high accuracy in a frame at the focus of the ball lenses. The bundle of 60 fibres guides the light towards the sensors.
fibre bundle                                 fibre bundle assembly concept

close-up on the front lenslet
some views of the fibre bundle. Assembly (top left), cut and scale of the lenslet arrays with a 1 Euro coin (top right), and close-up of the lenslet array as mounted (bottom). On the latter, the entrance of the fibres can be seen as a green circle in the middle of each lenslet. Pictures courtesy S. Tordo, C. Dupuy.

At the connectorised end of each fiber, an individual APD (avalanche photodiode) has been placed, which signal will be transmitted to the RTC. A dedicated board -the counterboard- synchronises the vibration of the membrane with the detection of the photons, in order to measure the curvature at the level of the subaperture; the curvature follows:
curvature formula
The 60-elements curvature vector is then multiplied by a control matrix, to provide the command vector, sent to the deformable mirror's HVA (high voltage amplifier) in the form of 60 voltages. Additionally, a tip-tilt component is extracted from the 60 voltages, and sent to a dedicated tip-tilt mount. This allows reducing the load of the deformable mirror. The HVA is providing a +/-400V range, allowing to compensate with the DM up to 1.2" of seeing at 3 sigma. The controller used in the RTC follows the control law:
y[n]= y[n-1] – KI/2 (x[n] + x[n-1])- KP (x[n] – x[n-1])

where y is the position of the DM (in voltage, for example), and x is the voltage offset to the ideal WF, as measured by the WFS. n is the time index, n-1 is the index of the values provided during the last loop cycle. KI and KP are close to the integral and proportional gains classically defined in control theory.

loop principle loop principle 2
Control strategy for CRIRES. The classical sheme for AO applies: fast loop with the deformable mirror, realyed by the TT-mount loop for lower frequencies tip-tilt components, the TT-mount offloading itself on the telescope pointing control. MACAO-CRIRES feeding a spectrograph, a slit-viewer allows refining the pointing of the instrument at the observation wavelength (or close to it), and this loop is described in the second sketch, showing how the slit-viewer controls the field selector of the AO system for correcting the small offsets which appear between the visible AO-guiding and the infrared image on the 0.2" slit.


Calibration of the system
Several calibrations are regularly performed to maintain the performance of the system, the most important being:
  1. the phase lag calibration aims at synchronising the membrane mirror and the counterboard; the procedure applies a non-flat shape to the DM, and varies the phase lag so as to minimise the curvature signal seen by the WFS. A 90º offset is then applied to the counterboard which produces then the maximum signal.
    Frequency: weekly, during daytime.
  2. the RoC calibration: the radius of curvature defines the optical amplification of the curvature signal; the smaller the RoC, the bigger the amplification. There is a linear relationship between RoC and voltage amplitude applied to the membrane mirror, which can be calibrated by applying a known defocus to the calibration stage, and measure the curvature seen over the pupil while varying the voltage applied to the membrane mirror.
    Frequency: daily during daytime.
  3. The flat reference is computed each time another calibration is to be done, and before any observation where the adaptive optics can not be used (deeply embedded object, or extended object without contrasted central feature). With the appropriate procedure, its quality stays below 100 nm rms over a 4 hour period.
    Frequency: daily during daytime, and before any non-AO operation of the instrument.
  4. Interaction matrices must be computed for a series of interaction matrices, covering the optimal range of RoC used by the system. An interaction matrix records the curvature measured as a function of the voltage applied to the DM. It is therefore a 60x60 matrix which pseudo-inverse provides the control matrix used by the system in closed-loop. The use of the pseudo-inverse comes from the fact that a piston term produced by the DM produces a 0 curvature, not seen by the WFS: it is necessary to filter out one mode of the system to get an optimal correction.
    Frequency: weekly check, daytime.
  5. The pupil centring is measured  by estimating the curvature signal spread over the neighbours when an electrode is activated. A good centering will provide a pattern symetric around each electrode. Centring, rotation of the pattern and shrinking of the pupil can be measured together by acquiring a single interaction matrix.
    Frequency: daily check, daytime.
  6. Secondary interaction matrices are computed, by measuring the voltage pattern required on the DM to counteract a tip-tilt introduced by the mean of the tip-tilt mount.
    frequency: weekly check, daytime.
As can be noticed, all the calibrations can be done during daytime (excepted the calibration of the flat when a non-AO observation is planned), avoiding as much as possible any loss of operation.


wavefront of the 60 system modes of CRIRES eigenvalues for the CRIRES modes
wavefront corresponding to the system modes of CRIRES, and their respective eigenvalues.

secondary interaction matrix plot flat vector voltage
Left: Secondary interaction matrix plot (the two lines represent the DM voltages required to get a pure tip or tilt; the curves have been shifted up and down to improve their visibility)
Right: flat vector reference; the 3-sigma of the vector voltage is below 10% of the available stroke, the maximum used by one electrode is 13%, and two electrodes use more than 10% of the available stroke.
interaction matrix example; the almost diagonal pattern illustrates the advantage of the keystone geometry for the lenslet array, allowing a very good correspondance between actuation and local curvature. The matrix values are given in curvature per 400V (maximum stroke) for the DM.

difference IM-(IM)T for a pupil shift (central part). Such difference matrix is used as projection vector to measure pupil decenter.

Related papers

MACAO-CRIRES, a step towards high-resolution spectroscopy, SPIE 2004 (pdf version)
On-sky results of MACAO-CRIRES, SPIE 2006 (coming soon)




 [Projects and Developments] [VLT Instrumentation]  [ESO]  [Index]  [Search]  [Help]  [News]
Last update: 2006-07-04